Ireland and Spain – The End of Two Success Stories

After decades of poor economic performance marked by low economic growth, both Spain and Ireland have been economically and socially transformed over the past decade. Between 1990 and 2007 growth in Ireland averaged 6.5% whereas the Spanish economy has grown by close to 4% for the past decade. Recently however, both economies have suffered dramatically from the global financial and economic crisis exacerbated by domestic factors. In particular both economies had been suffering from housing bubbles that burst in the wake of the US sub-prime crisis.


JPEG - 66.6 ko
Both Ireland’s and Spain’s housing bubbles burst, challenging the countries’ economies.

Photo : « Concrete Forms » on flickr.com

It is worth noting, however, that the Spanish banks have proven to be far more resilient to the global financial storm than their Irish counter-parts. Partly as a consequence, the two countries’ responses to their economic woes have been dramatically different. Whereas Ireland, constrained by the measures taken to support its banking sector and its narrow tax base has been forced to cut expenditure and increase taxes, Spain has taken an approach based more on stimulating the economy with increased investment.

Ireland – The Death of a Celtic Tiger

Ireland as an open, globalised economy, reliant on exports and financial services with a high level of household debt and increasingly dependent on a housing bubble was particularly vulnerable to the crisis in global economy. A decline in exports, the crisis in the financial sector and a significant drop in consumer spending all contributed to a fall off in economic growth. Yet perhaps the most important factor in the rapid decline in the Irish economy remains, nonetheless, the bursting of the housing bubble. Its subsequent correction has led to a rapid slow-down in economic activity, a swift drop in housing prices and a reduction in incomes. The government has been forced to adopt a succession of measures to support the banking system including guaranteeing all bank deposits, recapitalization of the two largest institutions and nationalization of a particularly weak bank, the specialized property lender Anglo-Irish Bank. Most recently, in the second emergency budget of this year, the government created a « bad bank ». the National Asset Management Agency (NAMA) ,which will relieve Irish banks of an estimated €90 billion worth of property loans.

The result of this perfect economic storm has been a spectacular fall off in economic growth, rapidly rising unemployment and a crisis in the public finances. The Irish exchequer was particularly reliant on tax revenues flowing from the property and construction sector while successive cuts in income tax throughout the period of the Celtic Tiger led to a particularly narrow tax base. The collapse of the property market and the construction sector led to a rapid drop in tax revenue while increased numbers of unemployed resulted in increasing social welfare costs. The result is a growing gap between the Irish state’s income and expenditure. Despite introducing two emergency budgets this year alone and taking such drastic measures as imposing a 7.5% pension levy on public sector workers (in effect a pay cut) and raising taxes, the budget deficit is still set to reach up to 10% of GDP this year. This growing public deficit is expected to lead to a rapid increase of the public debt, expected to climb to over 60% of GDP in 2010. As would be expected, the political fallout from this dramatic change in fortunes has been significant. The social partnership process whereby unions, employers and the government would form agreements covering defined periods of time collapsed at the beginning of the year when trade unions pulled out, feeling unable to agree to spending and pay cuts proposed by the government.

JPEG - 54.7 ko
Irish Taioseach Brian Cowen shortly after the rejection of the Lisbon Treaty by the Irish electorate.

Photo : Audiovisual service of the European Commission.

The government having been in power for over ten years is widely considered responsible for what is seen as an economic disaster and confidence in the Taoiseach (Prime Minister) and the main government party (Fianna Fail) has plummeted. The main opposition parties of Fine Gael and Labour in particular, have been the main beneficiaries. Fine Gael for the first time in the history of the state has overtaken Fianna Fail as the most popular party and Labour is making significant gains in the opinion polls on the back of strong parliamentary performances by its leaders. Support from the junior party in government, the Greens, has remained solid over the crisis and some wonder if it will be Fianna Fail’s own backbenchers, facing increasingly hostile constituents, who may prove to be the weakest link in Brian Cowen’s majority. It remains to be seen if this government will be able to stay in power for the foreseeable future and it is expected to fare poorly in the upcoming local and European elections. One unexpected result of the crisis has been a reversal in the public’s attitude towards the Lisbon Treaty with a majority now supporting ratification the Treaty. Most attribute this to a perception by voters that the EU and the Euro provide a degree of security and support for a small economy in the current global environment.

Spain – The Denied Crisis

JPEG - 95.4 ko
José Luis Rodriguez Zapatero, Prime Minister of Spain, long denied the desperate state of the Spanish economy.

Photo : European Parliament.

On 9th March 2009 the Spanish government, led by Prime Minister José Luis Rodriguez Zapatero (Socialist Workers’ Party -PSOE-) reviewed the first year of his second term. After winning the elections in 2008 with a moderate majority (although not absolute), the electoral campaign, the elections and the following months were characterized by the Government’s denial of the crisis. Only on 8th July the President mentioned for the first time the previously taboo word in a TV interview. In March 2009 the Executive defined this first year as ‘reasonably positive’. However, despite this extraordinary lack of realism vis-à-vis the disastrous economic data, nobody in Spain seems to question Zapatero’s government resilience.

The key to understanding the magnitude of the Spanish crisis is the housing sector’s bubble and the large imbalance in the current-account deficit. Even in the rather optimistic macroeconomic forecast the Government made in mid January 2009, no economic sector showed signs of recovery. A contraction of 1.6% in real GDP and an unemployment rate of 15.9% are expected for 2009. The expansionary fiscal policy has focused so far on expenditure increases in infrastructure and investment, the stimulation of the enormous housing sector and the financing of SMEs. However, it risks being exhausted in the short term. Spain’s credit rating has been downgraded from AAA to AA+ in January and the government will face significant international borrowing constraints. In addition to that, during the first months of the crisis the Government used the resilience and healthy situation of the Spanish banks (Santander and BBVA published solid results in 2008), as evidence to publicly deny the crisis. However, at the end of March 2009 the Bank of Spain already announced the first public intervention in the regional savings bank of Castilla La Mancha.

Despite these devastating economic results, social unrest is not expected in the medium-term. Trade Unions are surprisingly restrained in their demands and public opinion perceives the Socialists as the best placed to offer welfare support in times of enormous unemployment. The main opposition party, the conservative Popular Party (PP) has been suffering for some months from a lack of clear leadership after defeat in the general elections. However, after the two regional elections on 1st March, they regained control of Galicia and will govern in coalition with the Socialist Party in the Basque Country (excluding the nationalist PNV from power for the first time in three decades). However in response the Basque nationalists have stopped to vote in favour of the socialist proposals, reducing the Government’s support in Madrid. The Socialists are now facing serious difficulties in gaining approval for the economic measures proposed from the beginning of March, which is for the first time raising some doubts about the Government’s resilience. There are already calls for a change in government after the European Elections in June. These elections may come to mark the beginning of a political crisis that will only become clear in due time.


reagir   Imprimer   envoyer par mail   Auteurs
Espace réactions ()

xavi
16 juin 2009
14:00
Ireland and Spain – The End of Two Success Stories

Jose Luis Rodriguez Zapatero is not the Prime Minister, he is the President of Spain.

Guadalupe
16 juin 2009
14:08
Ireland and Spain – The End of Two Success Stories

Thanks Xavi,

but you will probably know that Angloxason Media (and English translations of Spanish articles) frequently use the term ’Prime Minister’ to refer to our President to avoid confusion with the concept and functions a President undertakes in other countries. You can even check BBC. Voilà one example : http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/3...

It was too basic to be a mistake ! Thanks anyway

xavi
16 juin 2009
16:38
Ireland and Spain – The End of Two Success Stories

Thank you for your fast answer, Guadalupe !

Yes, I already knew what Anglosaxon Media do with the terms « President » and « Prime Minister ». But, if you don’t mind, let me tell you that, if the Media I use to read/watch did the same I would never know the difference between « President » and « Prime Minister ». Instead of this, I know the differences because they (the Media) call them by the right name.

This detail apart, I must tell you the article I read is really brilliant ! Thank you very much !

luis
24 juin 2009
08:48
Ireland and Spain – The End of Two Success Stories

Xavi, fuck off !!

cuñao
27 octobre 2009
11:28
Ireland and Spain – The End of Two Success Stories

One year after the financial bazaar’s crack, these two countries still are the greatest unemployment producers. Bricks and pain, a good title for this article…

Isa
28 octobre 2009
18:59
http://epp.eurostat.ec.eu ropa.eu/tg...
Ireland and Spain – The End of Two Success Stories

Cuñao, that doesn’t correspond with real figures. According to eurostat , Spain is the first followed by Latvia http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/tg...

Europe and the crisis
In difficult times such as these, it is more important than ever to come up with innovative political solutions that can contribute to fiscal (...)
Spain
“DRY and the events of 15th May 2011 have signalled a turning point”

Auteurs

Guadalupe PEREZ

Après avoir effectué à Madrid un Doctorat en communication politique sur le conflit du Sahara Occidental, Guadalupe a obtenu le diplôme de Sciences Politiques et Administratives du Collège d’Europe. Elle a ensuite fait un stage au bureau régional de (...)

Stephen Coutts

Après avoir achevé une licence de Droit et de Français dans sa ville natale de Cork et avoir passé une année d’étude à Montpellier, Stephen a obtenu un master en Droit européen au Collège d’Europe à Bruges. A la suite de cela, il fut assistant académique (...)

On the internet

The Economist:
Country Briefing Ireland

The Economist:
Country Briefing Spain
Who's been tweeting?
Facebook

Does the United Kingdom belong in the European Union?

Introducing the Euros du Village Group

- 5 websites run on a voluntary basis, and 4 specialised Eurosblogs

- More than 120 publications per month in five languages

- Analysis and opinions of European issues and 7 years experience of covering European affairs

Find us online: The Euros (EN), Euros du Village (FR), Gli Euros (IT), Die Euros (DE), Los Euros (ES)

Like The Euros on Facebook!!!

The Euros du Village Group

Politics
Economy
Media & Society
Green business
Internal Affairs
External Affairs
Institutions & Brussels Bubble
United Kingdom
EU 28
Rest of Europe
World
Eurosblogs
Frodi al bilancio UE: i dati del 2013
L’Europa @ torvergata
© Groupe Euros du Village 2010 | Legal notice | Site réalisé avec SPIP | Technical realisation and design : Media Animation & Euros du Village France